Showing posts with label budget. Show all posts
Showing posts with label budget. Show all posts

Friday, September 24, 2010

Cutting Politicians' Pay Over Deficits May Backfire

Yesterday at Cato@Liberty Marian Tupy blogged:

Having inherited an 8 percent budget deficit from the previous socialist government, the new conservative-liberal government of Slovakia has come up with a novel way of keeping budget deficits under control in the future. Starting in 2011, salaries of government ministers will rise and fall depending on the evolution of the fiscus. Thus, a budget deficit of 5 percent will translate to a 10 percent decrease in salaries, while an (unlikely) budget surplus of 5 percent will translate into a 10 percent rise in salaries, etc. It will be interesting to see if this new measure will truly result in a more responsible fiscal policy in the years to come.

Maybe, but it might backfire. Here's how:

Politicans who favor deficits--for whatever reason--may be able to claim the moral high ground by playing the martyr. The financial harm they do themselves by deficit-induced salary cuts could allow them signal their commitment to the public good.

Rather than making hard choices about whose political favors to reduce or eliminate, they could effectively be off the hook as long as the pay cuts are less important to them than maintaining and expanding their political power (especially rich, big government types). Deficits could get worse if this dynamic further weakens the remaining constraints on politicians to run deficits.

I could be wrong. It depends on the combination of formal institutions, informal rules of conduct, culture, etc, in Slovakia. Which I know nothing about. So we'll watch and learn.

Still, it wouldn't be near the top of my list of effective ways to constrain government budgets.

Wednesday, September 15, 2010

Surprise! A Political Cheap Shot from "Think Progress"

Matt Yglesias opines:

Conservative Senators are currently saying that they will filibuster a middle class tax cut unless that tax cut is paired with tax cuts that exclusively benefit rich people. That’s because they care—a lot—about reducing taxes on rich people. If they cared about reducing the deficit they could threaten to filibuster tax cuts unless paired with spending cuts. But they’re not doing that because they don’t care about the deficit.

What’s more, conservative columnists could urge them to do this. So could Fox News hosts and conservative talk radio stars. So could the Heritage Foundation, the American Action Network, the American Enterprise Institute, or the Cato Institute. But none of them are doing so. It’s true, again, that they separately say they favor cutting spending but none of them are urging members of congress to make tax cuts contingent on offsetting spending reductions.

It’s a question of scope. Tax policy is a huge issue in itself, as is EACH of the big spending cuts favored by supporters of limited government. Policymakers can only grapple with so much at a time, and since the tax debate is occurring now, they’re focused on taxes.

Improving incentives for savings and investment is key to long-term growth. High-earners (i.e., high-producers) tend to save more and be more sensitive to tax rate changes than others (not to mention bearing the greatest direct burden of taxes). It is therefore good tax policy to reduce rates especially at the top, not for whatever goes to the rich, but because of the benefits to the rest of us from greater investment and productivity.

When this tax debate has passed, I expect free-market people will be happy to discuss spending cuts. But one thing at a time.

Monday, September 13, 2010

Why the Spending Fetish?

A headline on Bloomberg.com today blares, "Rich Americans Save Tax Cuts Instead of Spending, Moody's Says."

Timothy Homan reports:

Hand the wealthiest Americans a tax cut and history suggests they will save the money rather than spend it.

Tax cuts in 2001 and 2003 under President George W. Bush were followed by increases in the saving rate among the rich, according to data from Moody’s Analytics Inc. When taxes were raised under Bill Clinton, the saving rate fell.

The findings may weaken arguments by Republicans and some Democrats in Congress who say allowing the Bush-era tax cuts for the wealthiest Americans to lapse will prompt them to reduce their spending, harming the economy.

Later in the article, economist Chris Cornell is quoted, "Spending by the top 5 percent of households seems much more closely tied to business- cycle issues than it does to tax-cut issues."

The entire article is based on a false premise. Why is it that we should care only what the wealthy spend?

What they save, after all, can become business investment, which is what has been hammered during this recession and especially by the extreme regime uncertainty that has characterized the past two years. The images below from this recent post by Cato scholar Mark Calabria reveals that consumption is back to normal, while fixed private investment is down by 20%. The fixation on spending reflects flawed neo-Keynesian reliance on over-aggregation and mythical "multipliers."









On the empirical point about the wealthy saving much of tax cuts, that seems consistent with the permanent income hypothesis, which postulates that we try to smooth consumption over our lives. Something that changes expectations of lifetime wealth tends to affect consumption patterns.

Tax cuts that are expected to be temporary, therefore, would mostly be saved, while those expected to be permanent would be mostly spent. If the wealthy save tax cuts, it's a clear sign they expect them to be raised again when the bills come due for the current government spending binge.

Saturday, September 4, 2010

Debt and Deficits: Only the Tip of the Angry Iceberg

Barely had I published my last entry, when the Washington Post came out with a story about how many Democrats are adding fiscal austerity pledges to their campaign platform. I'm unimpressed.

On one hand, it's good that politicians of both parties have finally come to understand that Americans are fed up with deficits and debt. On the other, Democrats in general and many Republicans are missing the bigger picture: the American people want a reevaluation of the proper role of government and how that role should be distributed among the levels of government.

It's not just about the money; it's about being accountability. And if private enterprise cannot successfully undertake some collective action and government can do better, it should be the most local government that can address it, which also happens to be the level most accountable to the people. Suggesting that a congressman from Ohio can be held accountable for education quality in Florida, or a senator from New York for road congestion in California, is simply preposterous.

It's also about being left alone. The decennial census is supposed to count inhabitants for the purpose of apportioning members of the House of Representatives, nothing more. Yet it has morphed into a vast treasure trove for social science researchers. It sounds benign, but besides the privacy issues, the conclusions of that research provide justification for any number of wasteful and often counterproductive interventions.

Americans want more than cheap talk about the federal budget. They want their national political representatives to fundamentally reconsider the role of the federal government, eliminating, privatizing, or transferring to the states those activities that are not within its proper scope.

Friday, September 3, 2010

Gerry Connolly (D-VA-11) is Fiscally Reckless

Over the past few weeks, I've received a number of snazzy glossy flyers--booklets, really--from the office of Congressman Gerry Connolly (D-Fairfax, VA) touting his fiscally conservative bonafides. His campaign site make similar claims with issues section including headings of "Fighting Wasteful Spending and Budget Deficits" and "Holding the Line on Taxes."

[Begin tangent: The flyers, by the way, apparently meet the guidelines of the House Franking Commission, the congressional body that oversees mailings from representatives to the people they represent to make sure they're constituent service rather than campaign materials. They're obviously campaign materials--I've only received them this summer, despite being "represented" by Mr. Connolly since January 3, 2009. Just another example of the incumbent protection scheme our leaders have established. For our own good, of course. End tangent]

So I wondered, just how fiscally responsible is Mr. Connolly? Let's look at his votes on the big issues. Did he come down on the side of taxpayers? ("No" means he voted "yes," that is, not fiscally responsible.)
- The failed "stimulus" bill: no and no.
- The spendthrift Fiscal Year 2010 Budget Resolution: no, no, and no.
- Cap-and-tax: no.
- A toothless pay-go (touted in his mailers): sure. A decent pay-go: no.
- EFCA, the union payback: no vote, but Connolly is a cosponsor.
- Obamacare: no, no, no.
- The "Homestar Energy Retrofit Act" boondoggle: no.
- "Deeming" the Fiscal Year 2011 budget passed instead of actually passing a budget: no.
- The teacher union bailout: no.
- A resolution to prevent Congress from passing major legislation during a post-election lame duck session, once the voters have rejected the Obama-Reid-Pelosi radical agenda: well, it wasn't a recorded vote, but no.

Want something more rigorous and systematic? Fine. In the first session of the 111th Congress, Gerry Connolly scored a grade of "F" on the National Taxpayers Union congressional report card with a whopping 6%.

Let's face it: glossy flyers notwithstanding, Gerry Connolly is not being responsible with taxpayer dollars. To my fellow residents of Virginia's 11th congressional district, let's encourage him to make a career change after November 2nd.

Tuesday, May 18, 2010

Constitutional Reform Needed Soon

It's been almost four months since I last blogged, courtesy of a rather heavy reading list for the final lap of grad school.

Twenty books and many discussions later, my grasp of constitutional economics has never been better. In a nutshell, constitutional economics has to do with how the basic rules of governance lead to different political and economic outcomes. The basic challenge is to escape anarchy or despotism by establishing the protective (military, police, courts) and productive (basic infrastructure, environmental protection, monetary policy) functions while constraining the ability of political actors to use the power of the state to redistribute. As it turns out, no advanced country seems to have figured out how to constrain redistribution very well.

In thinking about these issues, I've come to a few tentative conclusions. Politics as usual hasn't been very successful at limiting government. It looks like we need to think about constitutional reforms, such as
- Term limits (5 terms House, 2 terms Senate)
- Spending limits (inflation + population growth)
- Balanced budget requirements (spending = revenue two years before)
- Prohibition on new debt issue
- Two-year budgeting (budget odd years, oversight even years)
- Zero-base budgeting (all programs reconsidered each time)
- Periodic automatic program sunsets (without congressional reapproval, they go away)
- Putting all implicit debts (unfunded Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, and pension liabilities) on the official annual budget

All of these are aimed at limiting the discretion of politicians. They're our employees, after all, so why do we let them get away with acting like our masters? Government doesn't give us meaning, it's just an instrument to accomplish those necessary things that cannot by provided by voluntary action.

Forcing government to live within its means would stop the intergenerational theft that has run rampant for the last eighty years and force politicians to make choices about priorities. It would also make it easier to say 'no' to the special interests.

How these reforms could be implemented is unclear. But unless Greece's situation looks like fun, we better figure it out soon.

Sunday, September 27, 2009

Germany's Fusionist Election

Even as America's political class expands its dominance over the U.S. economy, German voters sent the opposite signal to Berlin in today's parliamentary elections.

Since Germany has proportional voting, the Bundestag has representation from five different parties. At the risk of major oversimplification, the major parties are roughly equivalent to the Republicans (Christian Democrats), Democrats (Social Democrats), Greens, Libertarians (Free Democrats, aka "Die Liberalen"), and Socialists. Of course, the latter three parties, though technically minor parties compared to the first two, bear little resemblance to their American brethren. Simply put, U.S. third parties have no prospect of attaining political power, so they radicalize much more than those in Germany and other proportional representation systems.

In any case, this election marks the end of the 'grand coaltion' of Social Democrats and Christian Democrats--a tenuous and relatively non-reformist coalition. The coming Christian Democrat and Liberal Democrat coalition is essentially a fusionist (in the Frank Meyer sense) coalition of conservatives and libertarians.

It's too soon to tell what policies they'll pursue, but tax relief and improving the business climate have been major parts of their platforms. This means casting off those regulations that are harmful, cutting spending, cutting taxes, and otherwise reducing the burden of government.

One hopes that they've learned from the Republicans that tax cuts without spending cuts doesn't really cut taxes, it just shifts that burden to the future. (Yes, my supply-side friends, I know that the dynamic effects of tax cuts can make up for part of the revenue loss, but rare is the tax cut that fully pays for itself.) Fortunately for Merkel and company, Germany's flabby welfare state offers plenty of fat to cut out.

Zum Wohl and viel Gluck!

Wednesday, March 4, 2009

Fairfax Budget Blues & School Choice

The County of Fairfax in which I now live is facing large budget deficits. I've just started to go through the Proposed FY2010 Budget, but I was struck by this image of proposed expenditures.

Spending on schools is a huge portion of the budget: $1.79 billion, or 54% of 3.31 billion, and that figure may exclude some relevant costs.

The projected enrollment for the current 2008-2009 school year is 168,384. If enrollment doesn't change that much, that works out to almost $11,000 per student per year.

Some have touted vouchers and education tax credits as the silver bullet to education quality problems, but they seem to be overlooked in budget discussions. We usually assume that spending less gets you less--and shortchanging our children's futures is obviously unacceptable--but isn't it possible that at least some of the spending isn't adding much to their education?

Andrew Coulson over at Cato crunched the numbers to see what would happen if Illinois, Texas, Wisconsin, and New York adopted an education tax credit, and he finds massive cost savings.

If savings in Fairfax County are anything comparable, something like this could take care of the budget crunch, improve choice, and enhance educational quality all at once. At least it's worth a look.

More budget analysis to come...